Cobalt costs have risen by greater than 25% since Glencore introduced it could shut its Mutanda mine and – in doing so – convey ahead expectations of a shortfall in cobalt provide.
However with different initiatives ramping up or within the pipeline, stockpiles to be labored by way of and a short-term method to uncooked supplies procurement, Chinese language battery-related consumers had been skeptical they’d be affected by tightness within the close to time period.
Mutanda, within the Democratic Republic of Congo, is anticipated to provide about 25,000 tonnes of cobalt in 2019 earlier than manufacturing is suspended on the finish of the yr. Glencore cited low cobalt costs as a part of its choice to position the asset on care and upkeep for at the least two years.
Fastmarkets’ benchmark worth evaluation for cobalt normal grade cobalt, in-whs Rotterdam, settled at $12.10-12.75 per lb on July 31, in contrast with highs of $43.70-44.45 per lb on the finish of April 2018.
Giant provide will increase since 2017 had been partially spurred by expectations of robust demand from the battery sector and, later, by the value rally that adopted. Actual consumption from the electrical automobile (EV) sector has not developed on the similar tempo, leaving the market in oversupply with costs reaching the almost three-year lows recorded on the finish of July.
Whereas long-term cobalt demand appears to be like wholesome – Glencore famous earlier this month that it was not contemplating the sale of its African copper-cobalt property – it had been anticipated that the cobalt surplus wouldn’t be absorbed till 2023-24, based on Fastmarkets’ battery uncooked supplies analysis crew. The cobalt market is now more likely to swing again into steadiness in 2021 given the looming closure at Mutanda, Fastmarkets analysts mentioned.
Metallic, salts and intermediates costs all rapidly responded to the Mutanda closure information. The usual-grade cobalt worth rose to $15.50-16.75 per lb on August 16, up by 28% since Glencore’s announcement
The information additionally triggered inquiries for cobalt hydroxide from consumers anticipating increased costs, who needed to lock in materials earlier than cobalt hydroxide payables and the underlying benchmark metallic worth climb additional.
“I’m keen to take items at 65% [against benchmark metal price], however suppliers are usually not actually providing,” a shopper mentioned.
Fastmarkets’ cobalt hydroxide payable indicator, min 30% Co, cif China, stands at 62-65% of the standard-grade cobalt worth evaluation (low finish) as of August 15, up by 5.eight% from 59-61% on July 31.
Whereas cobalt costs have reacted to the information and merchants have began to restock, shoppers alongside China’s battery provide chain remained skeptical of additional pronounced strikes, with the refreshed tightness nonetheless at the least a yr away.
“I don’t suppose 2020 is the problem; it’s what occurs after that,” one distributor supply instructed Fastmarkets.
The Chinese language market had began to maneuver increased on the finish of July amid a restoration in shopping for for the fourth quarter and speculative curiosity.
“The Glencore information added gasoline to the hearth of metallic having primarily based out already; it has constructed momentum,” a dealer mentioned.
Sellers have been emboldened to carry out for nonetheless increased costs because the Mutanda announcement, and consumers have been working with low inventory ranges, making purchases on a hand-to-mouth foundation for a lot of the yr, which means they’ve thus far accepted these gives.
Patrons anticipate instant availability and cautious consumption will deter sellers from pushing too onerous with their gives, citing ample shares, the potential revival of artisanal mining (after the wet season) and improvement of latest mining initiatives that had been delayed on account of low costs, ought to costs proceed to extend.
“Lots of junior miners and new initiatives are more likely to make up for the absence of Mutanda supplies as soon as the cobalt metallic worth rises to a worthwhile degree. For example, these Chinese language-invested mines will certainly ramp up manufacturing,” a second shopper mentioned. “There are uncooked supplies elsewhere.”
Fastmarkets’ battery analysis crew this week forecast a provide surplus of 14,000 tonnes in 2020, adjusted from a surplus at 16,000 tonnes beforehand.
Rising output from the likes of Glencore’s Katanga and Eurasian Assets Group’s (ERG) Metalkol Roan Tailings & Reclamation (RTR) challenge can effectively cowl the market as soon as Mutanda is absent, given present expectations of demand, sources mentioned. It’s attainable cobalt demand will cut back within the brief time period, earlier than electrical automobile adoption ramps up, on account of a choice for nickel-rich batteries and cobalt-free batteries after China’s EV coverage is phased out in 2020, the sources added.
“There’s lots of materials within the pipeline that can be utilized to cowl the shortfall. The Katanga stockpile will cowl a part of [it]; then RTR is ramping up, and Mutoshi, Chemaf and others are nonetheless producing,” a 3rd shopper mentioned.
Round 9,000-10,000 tonnes of fabric from Katanga will likely be produced however not bought this yr, pending remedy for top uranium ranges, Fastmarkets’ head of battery uncooked supplies analysis William Adams famous.
“Mutanda continues to be producing till the tip of this yr,” a fourth shopper mentioned. “And don’t overlook there are lots of shares mendacity at Durban port, in spite of everything, China hasn’t been shopping for lots this yr.”
Chinese language consumers’ choice for getting hydroxide on spot or short-term contracts this yr – a operate of uncertainty over the speed of battery demand and volatility round payables – additionally signifies that that materials isn’t dedicated to provide agreements.
“Cobalt hydroxide costs should be supported by the demand, however proper now the demand continues to be gloomy,” a fifth shopper mentioned. “Cobalt demand out of China within the brief time period [is a concern]; better use of lithium iron phosphate and lithium manganese oxide [batteries] isn’t good for cobalt,” he added.
By that token, Fastmarkets’ cobalt sulfate worth stabilized in China final week at 45,000-50,000 yuan ($6,389-7,099) per tonne, (20.5% Co foundation, exw China) on August 16, unchanged week on week amid downstream resistance to increased costs pending a change in downstream demand.
It’s value noting that a short-lived rally in worldwide cobalt metallic costs stalled in April this yr, in opposition to a backdrop of cautious sentiment in China, the place shares had been excessive and cobalt consumption from the battery sector stays modest.
Restocking forward of late 2020 momentum
With the short-term method to procurement, concentrate on ramping up provide that also leaves the cobalt market in a surplus subsequent yr, and relative flexibility round battery chemistries and related cobalt demand, Chinese language consumers stay assured they received’t face a scarcity within the close to time period.
However a deficit is within the playing cards over the long run. Based on Fastmarkets’ analysis analysts, cobalt demand from the EV sector will attain 75,000 tonnes in 2025, up from 9,500 tonnes in 2017.
Within the fallout from the Mutanda announcement, market members exterior China have begun their longer-term technique once more.
“Lots of the downstream [buyers] are incorrectly skeptical,” the primary buying and selling supply mentioned. “The information simply instructed me to get longer, sooner.”
Moreover, some market members instructed Fastmarkets the optimism, and up to date worth will increase, was underpinned by the outlook for higher demand from the battery sector within the fourth quarter, which had already been translated into rebounding cobalt metallic costs and hydroxide payables even forward of the announcement.
“We see a attainable knee-jerk response as much as $18 [per lb] someday in August and September, however then consolidation earlier than the value picks up once more within the second to fourth quarters in 2020,” Adams mentioned, forecasting sustainable worth momentum materializing from late subsequent yr.
“We see the refined market remaining in a surplus subsequent yr, however the inventory drawdown will likely be very constructive and that ought to assist costs later subsequent yr after which meaningfully in 2021,” Adams added.
The benchmark standard-grade cobalt worth will common $16-16.50 per lb within the fourth quarter and first half of 2020, rising to $18-19 per lb within the second half of subsequent yr, based on forecasts from Fastmarkets’ analysis crew.
“One reduce could make all of the distinction, however shares should be drawn down first,” Adams mentioned.
To seek out out what’s driving the battery uncooked supplies market be a part of our free webinar on Wednesday September 18. Register here.
Susan Zou in Shanghai contributed to this report.