Tesla has misplaced a significant $5 million order of 85 Mannequin three autos from a rental firm over issues with service and high quality of beforehand delivered automobiles.
Germany-based all-electric rental automotive firm nextmove ordered 100 Tesla Mannequin three autos so as to add their fleet final yr.
After taking supply of the primary 15 automobiles earlier this yr, the corporate skilled so many points that they got here again to Tesla wanting a assure of high quality and repair for the remaining 85 automobiles on the order, which was apparently value round 5 million euros.
nextmove wrote in an electronic mail:
“Tesla Mannequin three autos, which nextmove was presupposed to take over after fee and solely a brief examination, generally had critical defects: faulty tires, paint and physique damages, faulty cost controllers, mistaken wiring harnesses or lacking emergency name buttons. Such high quality defects would have endangered the security of the purchasers and the profitability of nextmove.”
The corporate documented a few of these points in a YouTube video launched at present inn German with English subtitles):
For the remainder of the order, the corporate requested Tesla for a promise of delivering the brand new autos in good situation and for on-time service.
nextmove Managing Director Stefan Moeller stated:
“We needed to insist on compliance with common high quality requirements and processes with a view to defend our renters and our enterprise mannequin.”
In keeping with the corporate, Tesla as an alternative determined to cancel the order.
Moeller says that Tesla is in “service hell” — a reference to Elon Musk’s “manufacturing hell” remark when the automaker was ramping up manufacturing of the Mannequin three.
Tesla has had points maintaining with service as its buyer fleet grows quickly with Mannequin three.
“We all know that Tesla needed to overcome the most important challenges as a result of deliveries began on the similar time in Europe and China. However by now processes should be in place that enable multiple in 4 autos to be delivered with out defects,” says Moeller. “Though we take into account the Mannequin three to be one of the best electrical automotive on this planet at present, we are actually banking closely on different producers coming onto the market with aggressive autos subsequent yr – and who additionally know customer support. However, in fact, we can even hold testing to see if Tesla can get out of service hell.”
nextmove says that it continued to strive shopping for Mannequin three’s from Tesla by way of on-line orders, however they declare that Tesla tried to promote them automobiles that had been already registered to different patrons earlier than.
They feared that it could have prevented them to take benefit from EV incentives in Germany.
We contacted Tesla about nextmove’s claims and we’ll replace if we get a solution.
Replace: Tesla despatched us the followinig assertion:
“Tesla’s car high quality has reached file highs, and our knowledge doesn’t point out any uncommon car high quality points which might be particular to Germany or anyplace else on this planet. Though there’s all the time a small probability automotive could often encounter blemishes throughout last transport to a buyer, that isn’t distinctive to Tesla and we deal with these points shortly for anybody impacted. We’re additionally within the technique of scaling up service facilities globally, together with a greater than 50% improve in Cell Service autos and a five-fold improve in Cell Service protection simply this yr in Europe.
We set a particularly excessive bar for our automobiles, which is why any buyer who’s sad with theirs can return it for a full refund as much as seven days after buy. Our buyer satisfaction knowledge reveals that German clients have largely been happy with their autos, together with the standard and situation of their automobiles upon supply.”
The automaker additionally claims that they didn’t cancel the order and that nextmove backed off of the plan due to one other dispute with Tesla.
Tesla additionally says that the difficulty with promoting autos that had been previoulsy registered to different patrons was on account of an issue with their VIN matching system that has been corrected.
Tesla had a rough launch of the Model 3 in Europe earlier this yr. A number of early clients suffered and it appears like nextmove was one in every of them.
Nevertheless, I don’t see why Tesla wasn’t keen to vow good deliveries going ahead and on-time service. Isn’t that what they’re presupposed to do within the first place?
We don’t have all the small print, however I really feel like nextmove may need been asking for extra insurance coverage than that for his or her industrial enterprise, which could have led to the order cancellation.
Both approach, it’s unhappy to see such an enormous order canceled, however Tesla is actively working to enhance service. It not too long ago introduced the opening of two new service centers in Germany.
Subscribe to Electrek on YouTube for exclusive videos and subscribe to the podcast.